Don’t know about you, but I am enjoying the racial speculation in baseball circles that has resulted from this and this. Far be it from me to answer the issues that have lead us to today, but surely we can examine the work of noted sociologist Nick Cafardo as he delves into the emotionally charged topic of race in American sports.
We have dealt with the decline in African-American participation in baseball quite a bit over the past few years, but the questions we raise remain difficult to answer.
Nothing like suggesting a question a thousand times, and admitting an incapability to answer as an opening to a 900 word piece. “I’ve tried and failed to answer this question before, I have no new evidence, but I do have a deadline!”
We know inner-city kids trend toward basketball and football.
And, for what it is worth, soccer is working hard to make in roads into the inner city. I am a massive sports fan, but maybe the conversation should move from “why aren’t these poor kids playing our sport” to, as Charles Barkley has reminded us, the injustice of thinking that sports are the only salvation of our inner city youth.
We know baseball doesn’t market its great African-American athletes like the NBA or NFL.
True. I never see Ryan Howard in Subway ads (or on The Office), Andrew McCutchen on video game covers, Torii Hunter giving interviews, David Price carting his dog around the whole Tampa Bay area to the point that his dog will have a bobblehead day on Sunday, or Jackie Bradley, Jr. having his own media fan club (Pete Abraham, president).
Even the celebration of Jackie Robinson through books and films doesn’t
seem to inspire African-American youth to play the game Robinson so loved, and paved the way for others to enjoy and participate.
Maybe we are looking at the whole issue from the wrong perspective. Do we really
expect books and movies to start a movement toward a particular sport?
Monday, April 15, 1947, was the day Robinson debuted against the Boston
Braves atEbbets Field, 66 years ago, as a first baseman (he later moved to second base). It is mind-boggling that Robinson’s story — which again is on
the silver screen — has not inspired more African-Americans to play baseball.
Has the story of Seabiscuit inspired you to join an Equestrian club?
It did at one time, because in 1975, 27 percent of major league players were
But what about the internationalization of baseball? What about the elite level of baseball coming from Asia, Latin America, the Caribbean Islands? We have not returned to a day where the game is whiter than a marshmallow. The game is vibrant and multi-national. Perhaps the rise of an international game has as much to do with the dip in some demographics in the game?
Would I like more African American players? Of course! I love elite baseball. But, are we creating problems here? Is it possible that we are being myopic in our view and in these reports? If Uncle Bud and his henchman are striving to make the game international as can be, there are going to be dips our demographic counts somewhere. The more brilliant Asian players that come over here to share their
exciting and talented brand of baseball, the more Americans of every color, race, and nation (remember, Mexico is American, too…North America) are left in AAA. Is there any correlation there?
Why hasn’t Robinson’s story inspired African-American families to attend more baseball games? There are still so few people of color at the ballpark on a given night.
Do you have stats to back that up? Eyeball test, indeed.
What about TV numbers? What about kids talking on the playground?
It isn’t that Major League Baseball isn’t trying to find solutions. Commissioner Bud Selighas [sic] put together a panel of baseball people and dignitaries in other fields to come up with some answers.
Yay for dignitaries! Young people are impressed by few things quite like they are dignitaries.
Maybe Bud could walk over to an elementary school and ask kids some questions.
Major League Baseball revealed some interesting data in its Player Diversity Report, released Nov. 13. Big-league 40-man rosters were 62 percent Caucasian, 28 percent Hispanic, 8 percent African-American, and 1 percent Asian.
Nick Cafardo no transition alert!
According to MLB records, the percentage of players on 2013 Opening Day 25-man rosters who identified themselves as African-American or black was approximately 8.5, consistent with the last few years. One positive return: The first round of the 2012 draft featured seven African-American players, the most by total and percentage (7 of 31, 22.6 percent) since 1992.
So. Things are changing? Headed in the right direction? I’m confused at the point…
The Giants have no black players. The Phillies have the most with five. The Red Sox, Diamondbacks, and Orioles each have only one.
“As a social institution, Major League Baseball has an enormous social responsibility to provide equal opportunities for all people, both on and off the field,” Selig said. “I am proud of the work we have done thus far with the RBI [Reviving Baseball in Inner Cities] program and the MLB Urban Youth Academies, but there is more that we must accomplish. We have seen a number of successful efforts with existing MLB task forces, and I believe we have selected the right people to effectively address the many factors associated with diversity in baseball.”
That’s the thing. The RBI program has been a noble undertaking. RBI has seen more than 200 of its kids drafted to major league teams. But it hasn’t created that interest of a kid gathering up his pals and heading over to the park for a pickup game, like Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, and Ernie Banks etc. used to do. Nowadays, if it’s not organized or structured, it usually doesn’t happen.
HOW DO YOU KNOW THIS? HOW?
Am I the only one who ever sees a father and son taking batting practice at the park down the road? Kids following their dad to the softball ball field and playing catch or ”500″ with the other kids?
Yes, it is a different generation. There are a million other things kids can do. But shouldn’t one of them be baseball? Is it too hard? Is it that much tougher to gather a glove and ball and head to the park than head to the basketball court? Is a glove and a bat more expensive than a good pair of basketball shoes and a ball?
Most parents I talk to think video games, excessive homework, and a fear of dangerous people are key reasons why kids are inside.
Also, only one kid needs to own a football or a basketball. Even when I was a child, it was tough to find baseball gloves and we often shared when teams swapped sides in the middle of the inning. Also, baseball equipment is not getting cheaper.
And, kids are not necessarily in nice basketball shoes.
Maybe it’s something that parents don’t emphasize, knowing perhaps that it’s tougher for kids to get into college on a baseball scholarship. Football gets eight times more scholarships than baseball. So, the great African-American athlete has a much better chance of getting a full ride for football than baseball.
BASEBALL PLAYERS HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE PAID OUT OF HIGH SCHOOL, WHICH IS NOT AN OPTION FOR FOOTBALL PLAYERS.
The visual part of it is also important. Let’s face it, LeBron James is everywhere. All over billboards and TV and YouTube. Who is baseball’s most prominent African-American athlete? Is it Matt Kemp or Giancarlo Stanton or Derek Jeter orJustin [sic] Upton or Prince Fielder or Adam Jones? Are they the centerpiece of our visual being? No.
Former Mariners star Ken Griffey Jr. told Larry Stone of the Seattle Times, “First of all, they’ve got to start off with better commercials. The commercials are [bad]. Think about it. You look at the NBA, NFL, their commercials, and they make you want to go out and play basketball, go play football. They show the excitement of the game itself. In baseball, it’s come to the [expletive] All-Star Game. And that’s it. They don’t show the excitement of the game.”
Every time an African-American athlete breaks onto the baseball scene, you wonder, will he be the one to spark the interest? The Red Sox introduced Jackie Bradley Jr. this year. He created excitement in spring training, but has fizzled lately.
Do we wonder that? I usually judge a player whether or not they can play, and race is an afterthought. Seriously. Any other assertion is borderline racism.
And the African-American athletes themselves sometimes feel overwhelmed by the burden. There was a time when Ellis Burks was the only African-American member of the Red Sox, and Burks felt all eyes were on him and was extremely uncomfortable. Bradley now is the only African-American member of the Red Sox, and when/if he is returned to the minors, the Sox will have none.
Thank you for the basic math, hair brained assertions, lack of conclusion, and general in-cohesion.
But seriously, I have the utmost respect for Major League Baseball players. None more than Jackie Robinson. The stories, the video, the numbers – he was an elite person and human being. I also so deeply respect the African Americans who have followed in his footsteps – Aaron, Mays, Griffey, Frank Thomas, etc. But I am seriously hoped we were at a point where we were past “minorities” in sports. I do not care if my first baseman is black, red, white, yellow, or purple. I want him to hit 30 homers and get on base at a .370 clip, while not hurting us in the field. Major League Baseball needs to do all it can to unearth those types of players. Little League, RBI, development programs on the islands, scouts in Latin America all have their part in this process.
Can we please stop asking racial questions about players? More than anything, I suspect we honor Jackie Robinson more by acknowledging that Jackie Bradley, Jr. is (errrrrrm…will be) a great ballplayer than if we call him a great African American ballplayer.